Forums

Topic: a basic support for uploading images

Posts 1 to 3 of 3

a-follower

Nowadays most major forums have their own image uploader, likely since (sensibly-sized) pictures don't significantly consume bandwidth (i.e. trivial monetary cost). Can be controlled by the staff by setting a maximum allowed resolution and file size.

There isn't any reliable third-party host anymore — Imgur now removes some images** and I remember seeing reports already a decade ago of them banning domains to prevent forum users from embedding images. All other hosts likely have worse retention, don't support hotlinking and/or may be discontinued at any time.

** https://webapps.stackexchange.com/a/176693/134950

If the DF users must rely on third-party services, I presume that a third of the current pics on the forum are gone by the end of 2026. Also the images may be replaced with ads, like Imageshack has acted***.

*** https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/263771/ban-imageshac...

[Edited by a-follower]

a-follower

Frosh

Are data URLs supported?

Edit: Doesn't seem so. Depending on the maximum size of a message, that might be a good workaround.

[Edited by Frosh]

Frosh

Switch Friend Code: SW-2685-3767-8292 | My Nintendo: Frosh | Bluesky: froshkiller.dev

antdickens

@a-follower thanks for the suggestion — I'll certainly raise it with the management team and we'll decide if we want to move forward.

This isn't a technical issue, we could of course allow uploads. However, there are risks attached, both from a security perspective and a legal perspective (copyright, illegal, CSAM, etc). We would need to use a third-party service to screen any images, and that would come at a cost.

@antdickens
Nintendo Life | Push Square | Pure Xbox | Time Extension

Switch Friend Code: SW-7806-7257-0597 | My Nintendo: antdickens | X: | Bluesky: antdickens.com

  • Page 1 of 1

Please login or sign up to reply to this topic