@Master_Cthulhu70 PS5 sales now exceed 100 million. Xbox Series total sales at 38 million. Series S total sales no more than 19 million. Even ignoring Nintendo Switch sales, Series S are less than 14 percent of the market.
Including Switch sales, Series S would account for less than 6 percent of the market.
That's called a tiny minority. You should check your figures before wading into an argument unarmed.
The commercial case for Series S for most developers and publishers outside of Microsoft themselves is very poor. Microsoft demanded from a weak position at the bottom of the market with minority hardware sales that developers split their attention, create for essentially two separate machines. It's not just a case of missing a disc drive or even a slower GPU. These have completely different memory configurations too: affecting critical aspects of game design. Not a simple "turn down the graphics." Tell a developer they MUST spend millions more dollars to support a version of a game you're certain less than 15 people from 100 with consoles will play.
This has proven to be a failed strategy for Microsoft and the evidence of the last 6 years is undeniable!
Only the most delusional could assess this as a positive given the reality of Microsoft's market position after this strategy has been allowed to play out.
Switch targeted the younger end of the market or perhaps the more budget conscious and crushed it.
Sony went for the established dominant home position with the correct vision and crushed it. More than double the sales of combined Microsoft hardware despite the choice Microsoft attempted to offer.
That's cold hard fact right there.
People were given the choice and only about 3 million people a year chose a Series S despite being far cheaper than all the other choices. Pitiful numbers. Lower budget stuff is ya know- supposed to sell in big volume! That's why Ford sell millions more cars than BMW.
Perhaps then you need to think a bit harder about whether your cheap = good logical fallacy made sense. Because it doesn't seem that way. It's my argument that holds up when you break down the numbers on what most people actually opted for.
If any hardware kept developers in check with their technical ambitions with one eye on mobile chipset performance it was Switch, and the eventual Switch 2. Which has already sold more units in a year than Series S in six.
Sony's decision to provide a lower cost console sans disc drive with the same chipset and not graphically fragment or negatively tier the experience for consumers OR developers was the way to go. For a very long time the cost of a Series S was not that far behind the cost of a PS5 digital either. The better value proposition was the machine with the full fat chipset. I don't see the Series S as anything other than a major mistake. Public developer criticism has come to light in bits and pieces over the years. Privately I suspect the feedback to Microsoft is even more negative.
Microsoft have been asking developers to make much more effort for considerably less reward to support a platform that has sold to a tiny minority of the overall 9th generation market. It certainly is not about accessibility. It is not about a good society mandating the needs of a minority be respected. Nobody needs or is owed a new games console.
If you can't afford the new console you just don't buy it and stick with what you have. That's a valuable life lesson. Too much of the decay of society today is the expectation of certain groups that they be given privileges they actually aren't owed at all, that must be earned.
In a very small narrow sense, there is nothing better than unboxing the shiny new generation games console you bought and paid for with money you earned yourself. That comes from someone who grew up poor and still made good buying every new console on launch with sweat, savings and foresight.
Imagine the terrible input lag. Rockstar games usually have pretty bad control input latency for a start: RDR2 etc. Now pair that with a 30FPS lock on a pretty weak streaming service like Xbox Cloud. Unplayable. At least wait until you have a PC version that'll run 60FPS server side and thus end up somewhat more playable over streaming.
DLSS tier upscaling is the key technology that has failed to reach the home consoles. It has really hurt them as they have aged. High On Life 2 is another good example: while not great on any platform, it has vastly superior image quality on a modest Nvidia GPU using DLSS while all the consoles it runs on suffer badly from poor image quality. It has proven a critical difference.
Of course for AMD consoles it should be FSR4 or a variant thereof. PS5 Pro has still not yet delivered the advances in upscaling expected from newer hardware. PSSR2 cannot come soon enough, it could be a serious enhancement for that machine if it has been correctly executed. One hopes for the best.
@speak_easy The secret sauce is they have the source code and can simply port the game across properly. The previous MGS2/3 games in the master collection were the bluepoint versions for PS3/X360.
Ultimately this is a game running on 20 year old hardware. Even if it were ported with a host of inefficiences there is so much more performance available on most consoles a straight 1080p 60FPS should not be too difficult. Inevitably relying on upscaling to a 4K output.
Of course this is Konami we are talking about here, so a fumble is possible.
720p on existing consoles is for me personally unacceptable. They do not have good enough upscaling to get away with Xbox 360 era resolutions. Simply put they cannot run all these features with good enough image quality and framerate. Recent Nvidia hardware comes through with the save on PC. It only really highlights how unrealistic UE5 was for console hardware targets. An engine with demands at least three years ahead of where it should have been for mainstream GPU performance. I don't know what they were thinking at Epic, I really don't.
@MemuAccount You just think wrong. A truly quality upscaler would certainly mean that image quality would be sufficient at a much lower render resolution and settings to reach 60FPS on this game.
Of course this resolution and setting reduction could be quite low, such like Alan Wake 2 needs to reach 60FPS on PS5 Pro. However the end result can still be very good IF the AI upscaler is very good, such as FSR4 and DLSS. This game needs 60FPS to appreciate it fully. The fact Sony do not have a good AI upscaler while touting the capability of PS5 Pro hardware to enable the possibility is a failure. It is something that should have been addressed with hard work on the software. Let's hope 2026 resolves these issues.
If Sony had a really good working AI upscaling solution PS5 Pro would be massively better off. The failure of PSSR with most implementations and developers hurts the potential of the hardware to deliver the kind of performance improvements that were touted. All you get here is a bit more resolution and the same mediocre TAA upscaling as the other consoles. That's it. The gap between the Pro and what a midrange Nvidia card can do because of DLSS and frame gen is significant. This is THE game where high framerates above 60FPS contribute enormously to the experience. It might have been possible with a refined upscaler on Pro. Sony really should be working hard on a possible PSSR2 and get it onto the playing board for devs in 2026.
You would think they might have tried a little harder with the GPU. The thing is supposed to be semi custom isn't it? People go to AMD because they have all the parts you can knock together, they have the best custom silicon team after years of console and NUC experience. I wouldn't expect a high end machine, because that was always the preserve of the PC market. However it seems like a missed opportunity to have something with 10/12GB of video memory at a minimum. Where's the 3GB GDDR7 memory modules for example? It seems a perfect fit for a machine like this.
Comments 9
Re: The Legacy of Xbox Series S: Why Microsoft's Pint-Sized Console Matters
@Master_Cthulhu70 PS5 sales now exceed 100 million. Xbox Series total sales at 38 million. Series S total sales no more than 19 million. Even ignoring Nintendo Switch sales, Series S are less than 14 percent of the market.
Including Switch sales, Series S would account for less than 6 percent of the market.
That's called a tiny minority. You should check your figures before wading into an argument unarmed.
The commercial case for Series S for most developers and publishers outside of Microsoft themselves is very poor. Microsoft demanded from a weak position at the bottom of the market with minority hardware sales that developers split their attention, create for essentially two separate machines. It's not just a case of missing a disc drive or even a slower GPU. These have completely different memory configurations too: affecting critical aspects of game design. Not a simple "turn down the graphics." Tell a developer they MUST spend millions more dollars to support a version of a game you're certain less than 15 people from 100 with consoles will play.
This has proven to be a failed strategy for Microsoft and the evidence of the last 6 years is undeniable!
Only the most delusional could assess this as a positive given the reality of Microsoft's market position after this strategy has been allowed to play out.
Switch targeted the younger end of the market or perhaps the more budget conscious and crushed it.
Sony went for the established dominant home position with the correct vision and crushed it. More than double the sales of combined Microsoft hardware despite the choice Microsoft attempted to offer.
That's cold hard fact right there.
People were given the choice and only about 3 million people a year chose a Series S despite being far cheaper than all the other choices. Pitiful numbers. Lower budget stuff is ya know- supposed to sell in big volume! That's why Ford sell millions more cars than BMW.
Perhaps then you need to think a bit harder about whether your cheap = good logical fallacy made sense. Because it doesn't seem that way. It's my argument that holds up when you break down the numbers on what most people actually opted for.
If any hardware kept developers in check with their technical ambitions with one eye on mobile chipset performance it was Switch, and the eventual Switch 2. Which has already sold more units in a year than Series S in six.
Series S is a nothing burger in this industry.
Re: The Legacy of Xbox Series S: Why Microsoft's Pint-Sized Console Matters
Sony's decision to provide a lower cost console sans disc drive with the same chipset and not graphically fragment or negatively tier the experience for consumers OR developers was the way to go. For a very long time the cost of a Series S was not that far behind the cost of a PS5 digital either. The better value proposition was the machine with the full fat chipset. I don't see the Series S as anything other than a major mistake. Public developer criticism has come to light in bits and pieces over the years. Privately I suspect the feedback to Microsoft is even more negative.
Microsoft have been asking developers to make much more effort for considerably less reward to support a platform that has sold to a tiny minority of the overall 9th generation market. It certainly is not about accessibility. It is not about a good society mandating the needs of a minority be respected. Nobody needs or is owed a new games console.
If you can't afford the new console you just don't buy it and stick with what you have. That's a valuable life lesson. Too much of the decay of society today is the expectation of certain groups that they be given privileges they actually aren't owed at all, that must be earned.
In a very small narrow sense, there is nothing better than unboxing the shiny new generation games console you bought and paid for with money you earned yourself. That comes from someone who grew up poor and still made good buying every new console on launch with sweat, savings and foresight.
Re: You Can Play GTA 6 on Xbox One
Imagine the terrible input lag. Rockstar games usually have pretty bad control input latency for a start: RDR2 etc. Now pair that with a 30FPS lock on a pretty weak streaming service like Xbox Cloud. Unplayable. At least wait until you have a PC version that'll run 60FPS server side and thus end up somewhat more playable over streaming.
Re: Review: DLSS Is The Game-Changer For Resident Evil Requiem's Impressive Switch 2 Port
DLSS tier upscaling is the key technology that has failed to reach the home consoles. It has really hurt them as they have aged. High On Life 2 is another good example: while not great on any platform, it has vastly superior image quality on a modest Nvidia GPU using DLSS while all the consoles it runs on suffer badly from poor image quality. It has proven a critical difference.
Of course for AMD consoles it should be FSR4 or a variant thereof. PS5 Pro has still not yet delivered the advances in upscaling expected from newer hardware. PSSR2 cannot come soon enough, it could be a serious enhancement for that machine if it has been correctly executed. One hopes for the best.
Re: The Metal Gear Solid 4 Remaster Can Finally Deliver On The Promise Of Its Earliest PS3 Demo
@speak_easy The secret sauce is they have the source code and can simply port the game across properly. The previous MGS2/3 games in the master collection were the bluepoint versions for PS3/X360.
Ultimately this is a game running on 20 year old hardware. Even if it were ported with a host of inefficiences there is so much more performance available on most consoles a straight 1080p 60FPS should not be too difficult. Inevitably relying on upscaling to a 4K output.
Of course this is Konami we are talking about here, so a fumble is possible.
Re: Review: High on Life 2 reignites the Unreal Engine 5 image quality/performance debate
720p on existing consoles is for me personally unacceptable. They do not have good enough upscaling to get away with Xbox 360 era resolutions. Simply put they cannot run all these features with good enough image quality and framerate. Recent Nvidia hardware comes through with the save on PC. It only really highlights how unrealistic UE5 was for console hardware targets. An engine with demands at least three years ahead of where it should have been for mainstream GPU performance. I don't know what they were thinking at Epic, I really don't.
Re: Review: Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024 Gets A Solid, Unsurprisingly Great PS5 Port
@MemuAccount You just think wrong. A truly quality upscaler would certainly mean that image quality would be sufficient at a much lower render resolution and settings to reach 60FPS on this game.
Of course this resolution and setting reduction could be quite low, such like Alan Wake 2 needs to reach 60FPS on PS5 Pro. However the end result can still be very good IF the AI upscaler is very good, such as FSR4 and DLSS. This game needs 60FPS to appreciate it fully. The fact Sony do not have a good AI upscaler while touting the capability of PS5 Pro hardware to enable the possibility is a failure. It is something that should have been addressed with hard work on the software. Let's hope 2026 resolves these issues.
Re: Review: Microsoft Flight Simulator 2024 Gets A Solid, Unsurprisingly Great PS5 Port
If Sony had a really good working AI upscaling solution PS5 Pro would be massively better off. The failure of PSSR with most implementations and developers hurts the potential of the hardware to deliver the kind of performance improvements that were touted. All you get here is a bit more resolution and the same mediocre TAA upscaling as the other consoles. That's it. The gap between the Pro and what a midrange Nvidia card can do because of DLSS and frame gen is significant. This is THE game where high framerates above 60FPS contribute enormously to the experience. It might have been possible with a refined upscaler on Pro. Sony really should be working hard on a possible PSSR2 and get it onto the playing board for devs in 2026.
Re: Feature: Hands-On with Steam Machine: Valve's New PC/Console Hybrid
You would think they might have tried a little harder with the GPU. The thing is supposed to be semi custom isn't it? People go to AMD because they have all the parts you can knock together, they have the best custom silicon team after years of console and NUC experience. I wouldn't expect a high end machine, because that was always the preserve of the PC market. However it seems like a missed opportunity to have something with 10/12GB of video memory at a minimum. Where's the 3GB GDDR7 memory modules for example? It seems a perfect fit for a machine like this.